Smarter Accounting Software. Sign-up for a free trial, no credit card needed!

Servant Keeper Office Online Alternative

Servant Keeper Office Online Alternative

Professional-Chartered-Account

Icon Systems is a simple-to-use alternative solution to Servant Keeper Office Online. Is your church looking to make the switch […]

Icon Systems is a simple-to-use alternative solution to Servant Keeper Office Online.

Is your church looking to make the switch from Servant Keeper Office Online or another version of Servant Keeper? If so we would love to chat with you about Icon Systems and what it can do for your church. Icon Systems is a simple-to-use solution with the power to grow for your future needs.

NOTE: The following offers our viewpoint on Servant Keeper’s product offering versus Icon Systems.

Churches Need A Web-Based Package – Not A Look-Alike.

Icon Systems is a true web-based package, unlike Servant Keeper. The distinction is important. While it looks like Servant Keeper is an online package, it has a limitation on how many users can access the system.

What this means is you can only have the program installed on ‘X’ number of computers. To get a comparable Servant Keeper system to Icon Systems which has unlimited users, you would need to purchase their largest package.

The total cost for this software package is => $1,798.88. Icon Systems’ average package is $649.00/year, a savings of $1,149.00 over Servant Keeper! Worst yet Servant Keeper does not include a church accounting package. Icon Systems comes with a fund-based accounting system specifically designed for churches.

The benefits of a true web-based package like Icon Systems:

  • Accessible from any device that has a web browser and Internet.
  • The freshest updated software is always running
  • We take care of all server and system-related maintenance like backup, upgrades, and so on.
  • As many users can use the system without further cost to the church.
  • No need for hardware requirements on computers.

Support Is An Extra Cost With Servant Keeper Office Online

Servant Keeper does offer support at an additional cost ($$$), unlike Icon Systems, where it’s included. Why does Icon Systems include technical support? Because most of our clients don’t have a full-time IT person on staff to help them with their church management software.

As noted above Servant Keeper charges by user licenses for their software. These user licenses come into play in how the church is charged for support. The more user licenses the church has, the more expensive the support package is. The support cost starts at around $300.00 for the first three user licenses. It goes up after three licenses. Adding the support cost to the steep software cost — the annual cost is now over $2,098.00.

Or choose Icon Systems for a savings of $1,449.00. Keep in mind Icon Systems includes accounting and Servant Keeper doesn’t. Thus Icon Systems saves you even more since there isn’t a second package to buy like Quickbooks. We further discuss this in the accounting section.

Upgrade Cost Using Servant Keeper Office Online

It is very important to calculate the total cost of ownership when trying to compare two or more systems. Generally, you don’t want to look at just one year’s cost, but take into account a minimum of five years. Why? Because more than likely you will need to upgrade it at least once if not twice in that time frame. When looking at only one year for a cost, the upgrade cost is missed since it doesn’t come up until year two or three.

With Icon Systems the software is upgraded at no cost, ever. True online systems work this way in 99% of the cases. They are what techies call SaaS — or Software as a Service. However, with Servant Keeper, there is an upgrade cost to get new features, as seen below. Because Servant Keeper is not a true online system, the client-side (your PC) component needs costly upgrades.

Upgrading costs money every year or so. The upgrade costs are added to the total cost of ownership for the year you upgraded. It is a cost that is often forgotten but can make or break a decision to go ahead with a particular software package.

Accounting That Churches Need

We touched on this earlier but it is worthwhile explaining it in more detail. Icon Systems comes with a fund accounting system that was vetted by a national top 25 CPA firm. Servant Keeper recommends to their clients a non-compliant church accounting system like Quickbooks. Because Icon Systems has this important software module at no additional cost, the church must take care when comparing the software packages.

The church would have to add the extra cost for this package (ie Quickbooks) to what they are paying for Servant Keeper to do an apple-to-apple comparison to Icon Systems. A package like Quickbooks costs an additional $720.00 per year. What a church pays for Quickbooks they could have the entire Icon Systems package ($649.00) plus more.

For a total package that includes Servant Keeper and Quickbooks accounting, the church would pay about 2,818.00 per year without upgrades. With Icon Systems ($649.00) they would save $2,169.00 per year since Icon Systems has its own accounting package.

With Icon Systems they would get

  • membership,
  • small group package,
  • attendance,
  • donations,
  • pledges,
  • communication,
  • church accounting.

What is really important is that Icon Systems accounting package is fund-based which is compliant for churches according to the FASB 958. Quickbooks, including Quickbooks for nonprofits’ online edition, is not compliant with this standard. There are only a few church management software packages that have a full accounting module included, and even fewer that are compliant with the FASB 958.

Summary

Software companies don’t make comparing prices easy because of the various pricing models they deploy. However, online systems have removed some of the complexity in pricing models because they don’t charge for things like upgrades and extra users. Online systems typically have fewer price points. On the other hand with Servant Keeper, the church must factor in support cost, initial software cost, upgrade cost, training cost, and the monthly cost into a total price. It also must factor in modules that are needed, but Servant Keeper does not provide accounting.

Selecting a church management system can be daunting even for the most seasoned person. It’s our hope that this post helps you to see through some of the noise and make a better software choice, even if it is not Icon Systems.

Browse Related Content

Church Software Programs Introduction Church software programs specialize in reducing costs for church operations and help to grow the […]

API Introduction The Icon Church Management software API (application programming interface) gives you maximum flexibility and power by allowing you […]

Which ChMS Is Better, All-In-One or Multiple Systems? Short answer — having an all-in-one church software is the better […]

Having trouble logging in? Please call or email us.

Church members must contact the church directly for login assistance.
Make sure to use a recent version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.

Scroll to Top